An S corp makes sense when your business generates enough profit (often over $40k-$80k net income) for tax savings on self-employment taxes to outweigh the added costs of payroll, accounting, and compliance, allowing owners to take a reasonable W-2 salary and distribute remaining profits untaxed for FICA/SE, while ensuring steady cash flow for regular payroll processing.
The "2% rule" for S Corporations treats shareholders owning more than 2% of the company's stock (or voting power) differently for fringe benefits, classifying them like partners in a partnership, not regular employees; this means benefits like health insurance premiums paid by the S Corp must be included as taxable wages on their W-2, rather than being tax-free, though the shareholder can often deduct these premiums as an "above-the-line" deduction. This rule prevents them from participating in tax-advantaged Section 125 cafeteria plans, making benefits like Health FSAs unavailable on a pre-tax basis.
I've heard it ranges from $45,000 to $70,000 in taxable income (your business's, not your own). Personally, I think if your business is making more than $60,000 in profit every year, then you should look into forming an S corp. Keep in mind that we're talking about taxable income, not gross revenue.
You choose an S corp over an LLC primarily for significant self-employment tax savings on profits, as S corp owners can pay a reasonable salary (subject to payroll taxes) and take remaining profits as distributions (not subject to self-employment tax). While an LLC offers flexibility, an S corp provides more structure, making it potentially better for larger profits or attracting investors, but it demands stricter formalities and compliance.
For a New Business
A corporation or LLC must file an S-Corp election within two months and 15 days (~75 days total) of the date of formation for the election to take effect in the first tax year.
S-Corp reasonable salary is the market-rate compensation you must pay yourself before taking distributions, typically ranging from $40,000-$150,000+, depending on your role, industry, and location. The IRS requires this to prevent payroll tax avoidance, with penalties reaching 20% plus interest for non-compliance.
As a pass-through entity, one of the biggest tax advantages of the S corp business structure is that it avoids double-taxation, which means S corps don't have to pay taxes at the federal level the way C corps do. Instead, S corp profits are only taxed once, on the personal tax returns of individual shareholders.
Becoming an S corp offers benefits like avoiding double taxation, limited personal liability, and potential self-employment tax savings, mainly by passing profits through to shareholders taxed at individual rates, protecting personal assets, and allowing owners to pay themselves a reasonable salary (subject to payroll tax) while taking remaining profits as distributions (not subject to self-employment tax). This structure provides a single level of taxation and can offer greater credibility and easier investment compared to sole proprietorships or partnerships.
Examples of S Corp tax savings
Likewise, the more profit your business earns, the more you'll save. You need to earn at least $40,000 in profit for an S Corp to make sense, though. Otherwise, the costs of forming and running it exceeds the benefits of an S Corp.
To avoid double taxation, one option is to structure the business as a “flow-through” or pass-through entity. In this setup, profits bypass corporate taxation and go directly to the business owners. The owners then report and pay taxes on their share of the income at their respective tax rates.
However, while purchasing real property through an S-Corp is legal, there are serious tax implications at play. If your S-Corp owns a residential property and the property is subsequently distributed to a shareholder, including yourself, any financial gains on the property become taxable at an unattractive rate.
The IRS will not object to the S- Corp making zero payments to the owner employee when the business is earning little or no income. But, when the business is making money, it must first pay the owner-employee a reasonable compensation before making any payroll tax-free distributions with any excess funds.
Taxes. While LLCs and S corporations are both pass-through entities, S corporations may have preferable self-employment taxes compared to the LLC because the owner can be treated as an employee and paid a reasonable salary. Taxes, including FICA, are taken out of that salary.
Certain types of corporations cannot elect to be S corporations, including certain financial institutions, insurance companies, and international sales corporations. The corporation must elect to be an S corporation by filing IRS Form 2553.
Because of pass-through taxation, the S corporation doesn't pay federal income tax on its business income the way a C corporation does.
S Corporations offer substantial benefits to many taxpayers running or starting a small business. The election can help shareholders reduce self-employment taxes, protect personal assets, and offer credibility and professionalism to the business.
Your S corporation can have a net loss for the year and do something that causes a salary. And if the IRS and/or the courts find that your S corporation did not pay you reasonable compensation, you can experience a new surprise salary, payroll taxes, and penalties. This will make your bad year worse.