Can a beneficiary challenge an executor?

Asked by: Dr. Taylor Hill DDS  |  Last update: February 24, 2025
Score: 4.7/5 (71 votes)

Unlike executors, beneficiaries can petition the court to have the executor removed if they are acting improperly or breaching their fiduciary duties. Beneficiaries can also petition the court to surcharge the executor if any of their actions financially harmed the estate. A probate lawyer can assist with this process.

Does beneficiary override executor?

So, the simple answer to can beneficiaries override an executor is Yes. But this possibility arises under specific circumstances. For instance, if the executor acts with malicious intent or engages in fraudulent activities or if they are unable to fulfill their duties.

Do all beneficiaries have to agree to sue an executor?

If the executor fails to meet their legal obligations, a beneficiary can sue them for breach of fiduciary duty. If there are multiple beneficiaries, all must agree on whether to sue an executor.

Who has more power, a beneficiary or executor?

While beneficiaries can often disagree with an executor's decisions, unless the executor clearly violates the terms of the will or breaches their fiduciary duty, there is typically nothing a beneficiary can do about it.

Can beneficiaries demand to see deceased bank statements?

Beneficiary Rights and Accounting

According to California Probate Code section 10950, if more than a year has passed since the beginning of probate administration and an accounting has not been filed, interested parties are entitled to file a petition with the court to make the executor to complete an accounting.

Can an Executor Override a Beneficiary? | RMO Lawyers

21 related questions found

How long can an executor withhold money from a beneficiary?

Q: Can an Executor Withhold Money From a Beneficiary in California? A: Executors do not have the authority to act outside the guidelines stipulated in the will. An executor cannot withhold money from a beneficiary unless they are directed to do so through a will or another court-enforceable document.

What if the beneficiary is not communicating with the executor?

If they are not settling the deceased's estate and moving the process along, someone else should take over. An executor can also be brought to court if they do not communicate with the beneficiaries. People should be told right away if they are included in a will.

What rights does a beneficiary have from an executor?

The most important rights of estate beneficiaries include: The right to receive the assets that were left to them in a timely manner. The right to receive information about estate administration (e.g., estate accountings) The right to request to suspend or remove an executor or administrator.

How to prove executor misconduct?

Progress from filing a formal complaint, include factual evidence showcasing the executor's breach of fiduciary duty. Evidentiary support might consist of documentation of misappropriated funds, proof of unpaid estate debts, or records of negligent misconduct.

Can an executor advance money to beneficiaries?

Before an executor can provide any funds to a beneficiary, they have to ensure that all the deceased's bills, taxes, and estate administration expenses are paid. The executor must notify any known creditors of the death so those creditors can make a claim against the estate.

Can an executor be contested?

An heir or beneficiary who thinks the executor is not doing as the will directs or is not acting in the interest of the estate has the right to appeal to the probate court.

Can I sue my sister for stealing my inheritance?

The California Probate Code allows for victims of inheritance theft to pursue double damages, treble damages, punitive damages, disinheritance of the thief, attorney's fees, and costs in particularly egregious circumstances, so often a letter that explains the potential consequences will be sufficient to convince your ...

Can an executor decide who gets what?

While executors have discretion in some areas, your core decision-making is bounded by: The deceased's will. You must follow their distribution wishes rather than diverging based on your own judgments.

Can the executor sell property without all beneficiaries approving?

In conclusion, selling a house in probate in California is a process governed by strict legal requirements and codes. Executors must navigate through court approvals, inform beneficiaries, and adhere to the probate codes to ensure a fair and lawful distribution of assets.

How much does it cost to change executors on a will?

Lawyers can charge a wide range of fees, but it's pretty common for the cost to be anywhere between $100 - $500.

What happens when beneficiaries disagree?

When beneficiaries disagree, it can drastically slow the distribution process. In some cases, severe disagreements may even lead to arbitration and estate litigation.

What if an executor lies to a beneficiary?

Beneficiaries Can Sue the Executor Personally for Fraud

In that case, the people who suffered a loss due to the fraud can initiate a lawsuit against the executor for fraud or any other causes of action. The court can remove an executor as the personal representative of the estate for committing fraud.

Can someone sue you for your inheritance?

Vulnerabilities of Inheritances to Lawsuits. Sadly, the answer to the question, “Can your inheritance be at risk of a lawsuit?” is “yes.” If you and your family members aren't careful, you may risk losing some or all of an inheritance during a legal battle.

Who holds an executor accountable?

Executors who violate their duty may face legal action by beneficiaries or creditors, although they cannot be held accountable for a decline in asset value unless it resulted from their unreasonable actions.

Can executor screw over beneficiary?

Executors are bound to the terms of the will, which means they are not permitted to change beneficiaries. The beneficiaries who were named by the decedent will remain beneficiaries so long as the portions of the will in which they appear are not invalidated through a successful will contest.

Who has more power, executor or beneficiary?

Since the executor has power over an estate, and beneficiaries stand to receive inheritances from the estate, it's easy to see why beneficiaries may not be comfortable with the arrangement.

Can a trustee sue a beneficiary for harassment?

Yes, a trustee can sue a beneficiary for harassment if the beneficiary's actions threaten the trust's integrity or the trustee's ability to perform their duties.

How do you deal with an uncooperative beneficiary?

Dealing with a problem beneficiary

California executors can overrule beneficiary wishes based on the decedent's will or court orders, and align actions with legal requirements. Before making such decisions, it's wise to consult a probate attorney in order to comply with regulations and avoid potential disputes.

How to deal with a difficult executor?

If the executor of your loved one's estate does not feel able to handle the job for any reason, make sure they know they can resign. Changing executors is a common occurrence, and the procedure for choosing a new one is clear, ensuring the estate will remain in good hands.

How do beneficiaries receive their money?

If you are the designated beneficiary on a deceased person's bank account, you typically can go to the bank immediately following their death to claim the asset. In general, there is no waiting period for beneficiaries to access the money; however, keep in mind that laws can vary by state and by bank.