Can a shareholder be held personally liable for receiving illegal dividends?

Asked by: Berniece Wiza  |  Last update: January 18, 2025
Score: 4.3/5 (56 votes)

Additionally, any board members who were present for the vote and failed to vote against the distribution may also be liable. Furthermore, any shareholders who knowingly receive unlawful corporate distributions may be personally liable for the value of each distribution.

What happens if the dividend payment was unlawful?

Under the Companies Act, 2006, the recipient of an unlawful dividend may be required to repay the amount. Shareholders become liable if they know the company was unable to support the payment at the time of issue.

When can shareholders be held personally liable?

First, a Court may impose individual shareholder liability where a plaintiff shows that the shareholder exercised complete domination over the corporation with respect to the transaction at issue and that such domination was used to commit a fraud or other wrong against the plaintiff.

What does a shareholder's obligation to repay an illegally declared dividend depend on?

Further, shareholders are required to repay unlawful dividends received, if they knew of the facts that made them unlawful (even if they did not appreciate that they made them unlawful).

Do shareholders have an enforceable right to dividends?

Prior to declaration, shareholders have no right to sue for the dividend, but upon declaration, they become creditors of the corporation and may sue if the company subsequently fails to pay the dividend.

How To (Semi) Legally Launder Money

40 related questions found

Can shareholders force a dividend payment?

No, a shareholder cannot insist on the company declaring a dividend. Directors can declare and pay a dividend or propose a dividend to be approved by the shareholders in general meeting.

Do companies have a legal obligation to shareholders?

In a corporation, the board of directors has a fiduciary duty to the shareholders, requiring the board to make decisions in the best interest of shareholders.

What happens if a company refuses to pay dividends?

HMRC could also impose fines and penalties for paying out illegal dividends. Shareholders, too, face serious repercussions if a company cannot pay dividends – they may not receive the dividend income they were expecting, and financial difficulties could arise from insufficient profits.

Is there a legal obligation to pay dividends?

Dividends are the payment of a corporation 's profits to its shareholders . Payment of dividends are not mandatory; rather, the board of directors may use its discretion to decide whether to invest the company's profits back into the company pay them out in dividends.

What happens if dividends are not paid?

(1) Where a dividend has been declared by a company but has not been paid or claimed within thirty days from the date of the declaration to any shareholder entitled to the payment of the dividend, the company shall, within seven days from the date of expiry of the said period of thirty days, transfer the total amount ...

What limits the personal liability of its shareholders?

Limitation of Liability for Shareholders

This means that shareholders are not personally liable for the debts and obligations of the corporation. Instead, their liability is limited to the amount of their investment in the corporation.

How to avoid piercing the corporate veil?

5 steps for maintaining personal asset protection and avoiding piercing the corporate veil
  1. Undertaking necessary formalities. ...
  2. Documenting your business actions. ...
  3. Don't comingle business and personal assets. ...
  4. Ensure adequate business capitalization. ...
  5. Make your corporate or LLC status known.

What are shareholders not allowed to do?

While some shareholders have voting rights, allowing them to make some company decisions, such as electing board members, they are now allowed to participate in every facet of a company. Shareholders are not allowed to participate in the day-to-day management of a company.

What happens if you don't cash a dividend check?

If you don't cash dividend checks, those checks and associated stock may be escheated unless you have made contact with the transfer agent. Since most states sell shares immediately, you will lose out on any market gains, dividends or stock splits that occur after the shares are sold.

What is a disguised distribution?

A disguised distribution is such a contractual legal act concluded between the company and its shareholder, whereby the company provides a material benefit to the shareholder, or to a person close to the shareholder, or to another third party on the shareholder's instruction, outside the scope of the lawful procedure ...

What happens if a company never pays dividends?

Newer companies, or those in the technology space, often opt instead to redirect profits back into the company for growth and expansion, so they do not pay dividends. Rather, this reinvestment of retained earnings is often reflected in a rising share price and capital gains for investors.

What three conditions must exist for dividends to be paid?

Therefore, cash dividends reduce both the Retained Earnings and Cash account balances. There are three prerequisites to paying a cash dividend: a decision by the board of directors, sufficient cash, and sufficient retained earnings. Four dates are associated with a cash dividend.

What is the nimble dividend rule?

Nimble Dividend Rule

This is designed to prevent a company from using prior year E&P deficits to offset the amount included as a dividend. The nimble dividend rule is of particular importance for investors in areas such as infrastructure investments, which may have long periods of deficits before becoming profitable.

What is the Cornell law on dividends?

When stock is sold, and a dividend is both declared and paid after the sale, such dividend is not gross income to the seller. When stock is sold after the declaration of a dividend and after the date as of which the seller becomes entitled to the dividend, the dividend ordinarily is income to the seller.

What are the consequences of illegal dividends?

Directors of a company making an unlawful dividend may be in breach of their own fiduciary duties in authorising or permitting the company to make an unlawful dividend and can be personally liable to repay the amount of the unlawful dividend themselves.

How do I claim an unpaid dividend from my company?

A claimant has to submit Form IEPF-5 on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs portal for which he / she needs to information like – Demat account number, applicant information, company information from which the amount is due with CIN number, details of share to be claimed and details of dividend amount to be claimed.

What are the rights of shareholders to dividends?

The decision to declare and pay dividends rests with the company's board of directors, and it depends on various factors such as the company's financial performance, cash flow, and future investment needs. Shareholders, while entitled to dividends if declared, cannot compel the company to pay them.

Can shareholders be held liable?

The shareholders may, however, become liable for the debts of the corporation either by agreement or by operation of law.

What is a breach of fiduciary duty for shareholders?

A fiduciary duty typically arises in cases in which one party has an obligation to act in the best interest of another party, such as a corporate board member's duty to company shareholders. A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when a party fails to fulfill its fiduciary duty to another party.

Are shareholders agreements enforceable?

Under Indian laws shareholders' agreements are not enforceable on third parties. It only binds the parties to the shareholders' agreement.