You generally pay less in self-employment taxes as an S Corp than a standard LLC (taxed as sole proprietorship), because S Corp owners take a "reasonable salary" (subject to payroll tax) and the remaining profit as distributions (not subject to self-employment tax). A standard LLC owner pays self-employment tax (Social Security/Medicare) on all net profits, making the S Corp election beneficial for profitable businesses (often $80k+ profit) to save money, despite the added administrative costs and formalities.
Many small businesses consider S corporations to be complex and burdensome. If you're a small business owner looking to protect your personal assets, an LLC is a good choice and is the most popular business structure for small enterprises.
An LLC is simpler, with fewer compliance requirements and pass-through taxation, making it ideal for small businesses. A corporation (Inc.) allows for easier investment and scalability but comes with stricter regulations and double taxation unless you elect S-Corp status.
Businesses switch from an LLC to an S Corp primarily for self-employment tax savings, where owners pay FICA taxes only on a "reasonable salary" (W-2) and not on remaining profits (distributions). This structure offers flexibility for growth, better investor appeal, and easier stock transfer, though it adds administrative complexity (more forms, formalities) and requires a reasonable salary to avoid IRS scrutiny, making it best for profitable businesses.
What is the tax rate for S corporations? The annual tax for S corporations is the greater of 1.5% of the corporation's net income or $800. Note: As of January 1, 2000, newly incorporated or qualified corporations are exempt from the annual minimum franchise tax for their first year of business.
The "2% rule" for S Corporations treats shareholders owning more than 2% of the company's stock (or voting power) differently for fringe benefits, classifying them like partners in a partnership, not regular employees; this means benefits like health insurance premiums paid by the S Corp must be included as taxable wages on their W-2, rather than being tax-free, though the shareholder can often deduct these premiums as an "above-the-line" deduction. This rule prevents them from participating in tax-advantaged Section 125 cafeteria plans, making benefits like Health FSAs unavailable on a pre-tax basis.
Who pays more taxes, an LLC or S Corp? Typically, an LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship pays more taxes and S Corp tax status means paying less in taxes. By default, an LLC pays taxes as a sole proprietorship, which includes self-employment tax on your total profits.
S-Corp reasonable salary is the market-rate compensation you must pay yourself before taking distributions, typically ranging from $40,000-$150,000+, depending on your role, industry, and location. The IRS requires this to prevent payroll tax avoidance, with penalties reaching 20% plus interest for non-compliance.
Sole Proprietorship has the lowest tax rate between business entities.
As a result, you can pay yourself once annually. However, note that there may be an obligation to file Form 941 reports (whether you have taxes to report or not) on a quarterly basis, so you should take that into consideration.
Your S corporation can have a net loss for the year and do something that causes a salary. And if the IRS and/or the courts find that your S corporation did not pay you reasonable compensation, you can experience a new surprise salary, payroll taxes, and penalties. This will make your bad year worse.
Examples of S Corp tax savings
Likewise, the more profit your business earns, the more you'll save. You need to earn at least $40,000 in profit for an S Corp to make sense, though. Otherwise, the costs of forming and running it exceeds the benefits of an S Corp.
You choose an S corp over an LLC primarily for significant self-employment tax savings on profits, as S corp owners can pay a reasonable salary (subject to payroll taxes) and take remaining profits as distributions (not subject to self-employment tax). While an LLC offers flexibility, an S corp provides more structure, making it potentially better for larger profits or attracting investors, but it demands stricter formalities and compliance.
S-Corp election lets you split your profits into “shareholder wages” (subject to 15.3% self-employment taxes) and “distributive share” (NOT subject to 15.3% self-employment taxes). Active owners in an S-Corp must pay themselves a reasonable salary, but realize a 15.3% savings on the rest of their retained profits.
Taking an S Corp election allows business owners to split their income and earnings between payroll and ordinary income. Ordinary income is not subject to self-employment taxes because the income of an S Corp is generally taxed to the shareholders of the corporation rather than to the corporation itself.