Unfortunately, no, paying off your auto loan doesn't reduce your insurance rates, but it does give you more control over the type and amount of coverage you have, which can help you save money on your insurance.
Drivers that paid off their loans are no longer required to carry full coverage. If their budgets had been strained due to paying for full coverage, then they should decrease their coverage and premiums. Drivers can support the costs of a replacement.
The takeaway
Financing your car means a higher insurance premium. When financing a car, your lender will require collision and comprehensive coverage — also called full coverage. Collision and comprehensive repair your car in the event of an accident or mishap. Full coverage will increase your premium costs.
Prepayment penalties
The lender makes money from the interest you pay on your loan each month. Repaying a loan early usually means you won't pay any more interest, but there could be an early prepayment fee. The cost of those fees may be more than the interest you'll pay over the rest of the loan.
Strictly speaking, there is no additional cost for auto insurance if you have a loan on a car—as long as the coverage is the same in both cases. But that won't always be true, and that's why your auto insurance may be higher if you have a car loan.
Financing Won't Hurt Insurance Rates
The simple act of financing a car (versus paying with cash) has no real effect on your insurance rates: If you have a $500 deductible, your rates should be the same whether you've financed the car or you own it outright.
In some cases, paying off your car loan early can negatively affect your credit score. Paying off your car loan early can hurt your credit because open positive accounts have a greater impact on your credit score than closed accounts—but there are other factors to consider too.
Credit utilization — the portion of your credit limits that you are currently using — is a significant factor in credit scores. It is one reason your credit score could drop a little after you pay off debt, particularly if you close the account.
You have a little extra money and you'd love to pay off your personal loan early. Doing so will save you on interest and put a few extra dollars to spend in your pocket each month. So, should you repay your personal loan ahead of schedule? Paying off debt is generally good for your finances—and good for your credit.
Should I pay my car off if I have the money? Consider paying off your car if you can do so without sacrificing higher priority goals, such as paying down higher interest debt or having an emergency fund. Depending on your balance and interest rate, you may save a significant amount in interest.
Unlike when you have a loan or lease, owning your car means there's no financing or leasing company requiring you to have comprehensive or collision coverage. Therefore, you may have the flexibility to decrease your coverage and get a cheaper rate once your car is paid in full.
If you financed your car, most auto lenders won't allow you to cancel or suspend car insurance until the vehicle is paid off. Canceling car insurance can result in a lapse in coverage that will increase your premiums later. Your car isn't protected from fire, theft, or other damage if you cancel or suspend insurance.
You don't need to wait until it's time to renew your auto policy if you want to switch insurance companies– you can do it at any time. However, some may impose a cancellation fee for dropping a policy. If you have financed or leased your vehicle, you'll need to alert your lender because it holds the title on your car.
If you're still paying off your auto loan or lease, your lender will probably require you to have collision insurance because it helps protect their investment if the car gets totaled.
Once you've paid off your loan, your lien should be satisfied and the lien holder should send you the title or a release document in a reasonable amount of time. Once you receive either of these documents, follow your state's protocol for transferring the title to your name.
The standard rule of thumb used to be that car owners should drop collision and comprehensive insurance when the car was five or six years old, or when the mileage reached the 100,000 mark. (Plenty of websites weigh in on this.)
In general, however, you could see an improvement in your credit as soon as one or two months after you pay off the debt.
It will take about six months of credit activity to establish enough history for a FICO credit score, which is used in 90% of lending decisions. 1 FICO credit scores range from 300 to 850, and a score of over 700 is considered a good credit score. Scores over 800 are considered excellent.
While no set rule exists about when you should change your car insurance company, shopping around is highly recommended every six to 12 months. Moreover, car insurance companies change their rates often. Rates can increase and decrease over time depending on where you live and a variety of other factors.
While the person who owns a car is usually the one who insures it, most states will allow policies to be paid by someone other than the owner. However, many will not insure a car if the policyholder and car owner are not the same.
Progressive is rated No. 8 on our list of the Best Car Insurance Companies of 2022, and many drivers may be able to find better coverage elsewhere.
Unfortunately, as of June 2011 no person can own a car without it being insured, even if you're not driving it. This applies for cars that are kept on a public road, in the driveway or in your garage.
The Bottom Line. It would be nice if you could simply cancel your auto insurance while you're not driving your car. In reality, however, it's not that simple. Going without auto insurance can put your physical and financial health at risk, which could end up costing you much more than any savings in premiums.
Don't worry, canceling your car insurance won't hurt your credit score. But if you cancel your car insurance while you still have a car, future insurers will see that you had a lapse in coverage, which can raise your rates.