Is it bad to trade in a car you still owe on?

Asked by: Dr. Torey Yundt  |  Last update: August 6, 2025
Score: 4.6/5 (8 votes)

If your equity is positive, you may be in a good position to trade in your vehicle even though it is not yet paid off. Negative equity, however, may be more costly than you might expect or are willing to pay.

What happens if I trade in a car I still owe on?

In most instances, yes, you can trade in a car with a loan, and some dealers might roll your remaining balance into a new loan. But trading in your car doesn't make your loan disappear. You will still have to pay off the remaining loan balance that your trade-in amount doesn't cover.

Is it bad to trade in a car you haven't paid off?

It won't affect the value any. People trade in cars they still owe on all the time. You'll agree on a trade value with the dealer and they will pay off your loan for you, and the rest of the trade value will go towards the new car.

Is it better to pay off a car before a trade-in?

Clear Title: Paying off the loan gives you a clear title to the vehicle, which can simplify the trade-in process. Better Negotiation Power: A paid-off vehicle can give you more leverage during negotiations, as dealerships may be more willing to offer a better trade-in value for a car without any liens.

How do I get rid of my car but I still owe on it?

  • Contact Your Lender: Start by reaching out to your lender to discuss your situation. They may have options available, such as a loan modification or a deferment, especially if you're facing financial hardship.
  • Sell the Car: If the car has any salvage value, you could sell it for parts.
  • Tr

How to Trade in a Car you Owe Money on or is NOT Paid Off (Former Dealer Explains)

42 related questions found

Can I sell my car to a dealership if I still owe money on it?

You can sell your car if you still owe money on it. But you'll need to pay off the debt before you can transfer the title to the car's new owner. The process differs depending on whether you're selling the car to a dealership or a private buyer.

Does surrendering a car hurt your credit?

Losing your car can hurt your credit quite a bit unfortunately. Having your car repossessed or surrendering it voluntarily is seen as a major negative event by lenders. They'll view you as high-risk. Expect your credit score to take a big hit, maybe over 100 points or more.

When should I not trade in my car?

Although you can trade in a car that's not yet paid off, it's usually best to wait until the vehicle has been entirely paid off before you trade it in—especially if your car is worth less than what you owe on it.

What happens if I don't want my financed car anymore?

Consider a Voluntary Repossession

When you agree to a voluntary repossession, you start by informing the lender that you can't make the monthly payments anymore. The lender will provide a time and place to meet for surrender. Keep a record of when and where you dropped the vehicle off and who took possession of it.

Does trading in a car hurt your credit?

So, you can find out the value of your car and sell it to the dealer without thinking about your credit. If you are selling or trading in your car for another model, though, and are planning on financing, the inquiry process can impact your score. However, the vehicle trade-in itself carries no weight.

What not to say when trading in a car?

Telling a salesperson upfront that you have a trade-in adds another ingredient to the car-buying stew they'll cook up for you. The more numbers you have in the game, the more chances they have to manipulate the final price or monthly payment.

Can I return my car to the dealership if I still owe?

No! You signed a contract. If you return it they will resell it probably for a lot less than you owe and you have to pay the difference! What can I do to get my down payment from a car dealership?

How much negative equity is too much?

How Much Negative Equity Is Too Much on a Car? The maximum negative equity that can be transferred to your new car is around 125% . It means your loan value should not be more than 125% of your car's actual worth. If it is more than 125% then your next car's loan would not be approved.

What credit score do I need to trade in my car?

Your credit score won't impact the trade-in value of your car, but it will affect the interest rate you're able to get on the next vehicle you buy. Check your credit score before you begin the process, and if it's in the mid-600s or below, consider taking steps to improve your credit before you continue.

Does refinancing a car hurt your credit?

Yes, refinancing your auto loan will usually hurt your credit a little. But if you make your new loan payments on time, any damage to your score will likely be both temporary and small. Your credit could bounce back to its current score in as little as a few months.

Should I trade in a car that is not paid off?

If your equity is positive, you may be in a good position to trade in your vehicle even though it is not yet paid off. Negative equity, however, may be more costly than you might expect or are willing to pay.

How do I get rid of a car I still owe money on?

Selling a vehicle and using the proceeds to pay off the loan in full can help you eliminate the debt without hurting your credit. You might also consider trading in the vehicle and rolling negative equity into a new car loan to avoid credit score damage; however, that can leave you with more debt to repay.

Can a dealership repo my car for not paying down payment?

They can sue you for the balance you didn't pay for the down payment, but unless it was in the contract they can repossess, the law in CA doesn't allow it. Under California law, a breach of contract occurs when one party fails to fulfill a legal duty the contract created and causes damages for the defendant.

Does returning a financed car hurt your credit?

Does voluntary repossession hurt your credit? Voluntary surrender counts as a derogatory or negative mark and will stay on your credit reports for up to seven years. This stain on your credit reports might prevent you from being approved for new credit and your terms, like interest rates, will likely be higher.

Should I fix up my car before trade in?

Fix My Car Before Trade: Avoid Fixing Major Repairs

The more you spend on those larger repairs, the less you're actually getting from your trade-in value. Since the dealership has the expertise and access to tools and parts, they can easily fix major issues at a lower cost than you'll spend out of pocket.

Can I sell my car if I still owe on it?

You can sell a car with a loan but you'll need to give the full payoff amount to your lender before they'll release the car title. You can do this with your funds after you complete the sale, or you can refinance your car loan or apply for a personal loan.

How to not get screwed on a trade-in?

Make sure you're getting a competitive offer on your trade-in by getting multiple offers. Getting multiple appraisals is smart because the prices you're offered can vary from dealership to dealership. It depends on each dealer's current inventory, how confident they are in selling the trade-in, and other factors.

How to get rid of a car you can't afford?

In this article:
  1. Contact Your Lender.
  2. Request a Deferral.
  3. Refinance Your Car Loan.
  4. Trade In or Sell Your Vehicle.
  5. Ask Friends or Family for a Loan.
  6. Get a Side Hustle.
  7. Voluntarily Surrender the Car.

Is a voluntary repo better than a repo?

Voluntary car repossession is only a slightly better option than involuntary repossession. You may be a bit more prepared and have some control over when you surrender your car if it's voluntary. Avoiding some of the extra fees that can come with involuntary repossession can be helpful, too.

Can I sell my car back to the dealership?

Can you sell a car to a dealership? Yes, and selling a car to a dealer is a simple way to get rid of a vehicle you no longer want. It can be a good solution if you need quick cash to buy a new vehicle or an easy way to unload a used car without replacing it.