Lexus stands at the top of the competition in terms of dependability with a score of 135 PP100. This is a full 55 problems per 100 vehicles lower than the industry average of 190 PP 100 Compared to the BMW score of 190 PP100, exactly average. Lexus is the clear winner in terms of dependability.
Toyota is on top . Last year's second-place finisher has replaced its sister luxury brand Lexus at the top of Consumer Report's reliability ranking list. The two tied with a rounded-up predicted reliability score of 72, but Toyota was a few decimals better, and they were followed by BMW (65), Mazda (65) and Honda (62).
BMW scored 184 problems per 100 vehicles, with 186 as the average, for vehicles in service since the 2020 model year. So yes, BMW's reliability is still up there! iSeeCars: The BMW M6 is on a top 10 list from iSeeCars of the Longest-Lasting Sports Cars, with some lasting over 200,000 miles.
High Ownership Costs (Con)
Owning a BMW comes with higher-than-average ownership costs. Premium gasoline, high-end tires, imported parts, and specialized labor contribute to the overall expenses. Additionally, BMWs typically require synthetic oil changes, which further elevate maintenance costs.
When it comes to choosing a reliable BMW model, the 3 Series, 5 Series, and X5 stand out as top choices. Each of these models offers a combination of performance, luxury, and dependability, making them excellent options for any BMW enthusiast.
Winner: Mercedes-Benz
Lexus makes some sporty vehicles with agile road manners and powerful engines, but most of its lineup focuses heavily on comfort. The Mercedes-Benz roster offers better performance overall. Mercedes cars and SUVs generally feel more composed around corners than their Lexus rivals.
That being said, some recent studies show that BMW models can last up to 200,000 to 250,000 miles, with an average lifespan of at least 15 years. On the other hand, Mercedes-Benz vehicles tend to last up to 150,000 to 200,000 miles with an average lifespan of over 10 years.
Is Lexus cheaper to maintain than BMW? Yes – generally, Lexus vehicles are more affordable to maintain than BMW models. According to RepairPal, BMW vehicles have a typical annual repair cost of $9683. That's more than $400 spent annually on maintenance than the average Lexus.
Cars similar to 2025 Lexus IS. Both BMW and Mercedes-Benz pack a ton of tech into their 3-Series and C-Class models, which are available in a wide range of configurations with seemingly endless options lists.
Reliability: Lexus SUV models and cars are renowned for their reliability and durability, which is backed by the brand's outstanding record of dependability and long-term value.
Subaru Tops Reliability
Subaru has ascended to the top of our brand rankings, supplanting Lexus and Toyota, which have traded the two top spots for many years.
BMW and Mercedes-Benz are both great options and it is highly unlikely that you will be disappointed whichever you choose. For an enjoyable and immersive driving experience, BMW is your best bet, while for sheer luxury, safety and comfort, Mercedes might be a better fit.
Lexus performed well against the competition in terms of dependability with a score of 135 PP100. This is a full 55 problems per 100 vehicles lower than the industry average of 190 PP100. Compared to the Audi score of 275 PP100, Lexus is the clear winner in terms of dependability.
BMW vs.
Not only is Lexus a more dependable brand, but its average annual maintenance costs are also lower than BMW's. On average, Lexus owners report spending approximately $550 per year on maintenance. Comparatively, BMW owners report spending an average of $1,000 to $1,700 per year to maintain their vehicle.
Lexus is sometimes referred to as a premium, rather than a luxury, brand thanks to its cars' attractive prices (the LS and LC sedans, the LX SUV and the forthcoming 2025 supercar are the only Lexus models that retail for over $80k).
Lexus and Mercedes-Benz are two of the most well-known brands in the luxury car space. Nevertheless, the Mercedes-Benz brand's reliability and reputation can't be duplicated.
The E21 3 series, E34 5 series, E38, E83, and E36 models come highly recommended for their enduring quality and value. On the other hand, it's wise to steer clear of the E46, E60, and E65 due to their less-than-stellar reliability records.
Is maintenance on a BMW expensive? The maintenance on a BMW can be more expensive than other vehicles. As for the BMW inspection cost, it can vary but tends to be higher than inspections for non-luxury vehicles due to the brand's complexity and higher-quality components.
Of 26 brands, Lexus and Toyota top the list with a commanding advantage over third-ranked Mazda. All three brands have consistently earned average or better reliability ratings over the years. Honda and Acura round up the top five.
When it comes to brands, Lithia notes that mechanics say the most dependable auto brands are Honda and Toyota. These cars can, when properly maintained, take you 200,000 miles or more.