Should I file a claim with my insurance if it wasn't my fault?

Asked by: Annie Jerde  |  Last update: May 23, 2026
Score: 4.4/5 (54 votes)

Yes, it is generally advised to report the accident to your own insurance company, even if you were not at fault. While you can file the claim through the at-fault driver's insurance, notifying your own insurer protects you if the other party is uninsured, underinsured, denies liability, or if injuries are more severe than initially thought.

Should I make a claim if I'm not at fault?

Yes, you must report a non-fault accident to your insurer, even if the other driver offers to pay for damages and you don't make a claim.

Should I claim insurance for minor damage?

Do I still have to lodge a claim or is it optional to lodge a claim especially when the damage is minor? It is not necessary to always lodge a claim, especially for minor damages. In fact, most insurance experts advise policyholders to refrain from making claims for such damages. There are numerous reasons for this.

When should you not file an insurance claim?

1. The Damage is Less Than or Slightly Above Your Deductible. If repairs will cost $800 and your deductible is $500, you'll only get $300 from insurance—likely not worth the potential premium increase. This is especially true if you have previous claims on your record.

How much does your insurance go up by if you claim?

After a claim, insurance rates can rise anywhere from 0% to over 50%, depending heavily on fault (at-fault claims cause bigger hikes), the claim's severity (injuries, major damage cost more), your driving record, the type of claim (comprehensive vs. at-fault), your insurer, and location. At-fault accidents often lead to 20-50%+ increases for several years, while not-at-fault or comprehensive claims (like hail, theft) usually result in smaller, if any, increases.

Auto Insurance Claims Process: Not-At-Fault Accident

34 related questions found

Is it worth claiming insurance if my damage is small?

You might decide not claim if: the damage is only minor and it will be cheaper for you to pay for repairs yourself, instead of paying your insurer your excess amount. the damage only minor and the cost of your future insurance premiums will increase if you make a claim.

What are the 6 rules of insurance?

Basic Principles of Insurance

In the insurance world there are six basic principles that must be met, ie insurable interest, Utmost good faith, proximate cause, indemnity, subrogation and contribution.

Is it worth making a small insurance claim?

making a claim may increase your premiums in the future or when you renew your policy. some insurance companies offer a discount if you don't make any claims under your policy. if the amount of your claim is only a little more than your deductible, consider if it's worth it to pay for the loss or event yourself.

Why does my insurance go up if the accident wasn't my fault?

A not-at-fault accident can still increase your insurance because insurers see it as a sign of higher future risk, indicating you're statistically more likely to have another claim, even if you weren't to blame for the first one; they also consider administrative costs and your overall claims history, and some states allow rate hikes for any accident involvement to cover these increased risk factors. 

How do you prove it's not your fault?

How to Prove an Accident Wasn't Your Fault in 5 Steps

  1. Gather Evidence from the Scene. Documentation from the crash site is essential for illustrating who's at fault. ...
  2. Contact Witnesses. ...
  3. Get the Police Report. ...
  4. See a Doctor. ...
  5. Consult with an Attorney.

How does insurance work when it's not your fault?

So let's start with a basic definition: no-fault insurance, sometimes referred to as personal injury protection insurance (PIP), can help cover you and your passengers' medical expenses and loss of income in the event of a covered accident, regardless of who is found at fault.

Do I make a claim if it wasn't my fault?

What is a non-fault claim? A non-fault car insurance claim is one you make when a car accident isn't your fault. If you make a non-fault claim, your insurance provider can recover the total cost of the claim from the person whose fault it was. The person at fault is known as the liable party.

How does car insurance decide who is at fault?

Insurance companies rely on specific evidence to make their determination. While the process may appear simple, it involves carefully examining the details of the crash and analyzing what happened. However, if the insurer deems you at fault, you can lose your right to compensation.

What are the 7 P's of insurance?

The document discusses the 7 P's of marketing mix for insurance businesses - product, price, place, promotion, people, process, and physical evidence.

What are common breaches of insurance principles?

Insurance breach of contract happens when an insurer fails to fulfill its obligations as outlined in the policy. This can occur in various ways, such as wrongfully denying claims, misrepresenting policy exclusions, or failing to affirm or deny coverage within a reasonable time.

When not to make an insurance claim?

5 Situations When You Shouldn't File a Car Insurance Claim

  1. Single-Car Accidents in Which Damage to Your Vehicle Is Nominal. ...
  2. When the Claim Amount Is the Same or Less than the Deductible. ...
  3. When Your Insurance Rate Increase Will Cost More than the Out-Of-Pocket Repair Costs.

How much would my insurance go up if I claim?

After a claim, insurance rates can rise anywhere from 0% to over 50%, depending heavily on fault (at-fault claims cause bigger hikes), the claim's severity (injuries, major damage cost more), your driving record, the type of claim (comprehensive vs. at-fault), your insurer, and location. At-fault accidents often lead to 20-50%+ increases for several years, while not-at-fault or comprehensive claims (like hail, theft) usually result in smaller, if any, increases.

Should I file a claim even if not damaged?

Even without visible damage, it's important to treat the situation seriously. This can help protect you from future complications. If you were the at-fault driver, there's a possibility the other motorist could file a surprise (and possibly frivolous) accident claim or personal injury claim.

Is it better to file a claim or pay out-of-pocket?

Firstly, if the cost of repairs or services falls below your insurance deductible, opting out of pocket may prove more cost-effective. Additionally, choosing to pay out of pocket can help prevent potential increases in insurance premiums, especially if filing a claim would only marginally exceed your deductible.

What is the most common car insurance claim?

The most common type of car insurance claim

Collision claims were the most common type of claim recorded in the 12 months to August 2024, with a total of 104,857 lodged – almost double the combined amount of the other top claims.

Is 3 points a big deal?

When you get these penalty points, they can affect various areas of your life, including your car insurance premiums. Drivers with 3-9 points can expect their car insurance to rise, and the points could also affect your credit rating, your job and other insurance premiums such as life insurance.