What is the downside of depreciation rental property?

Asked by: Eunice Murphy  |  Last update: October 2, 2026
Score: 5/5 (65 votes)

The primary downside of rental property depreciation is the depreciation recapture tax, which requires investors to pay taxes on previously claimed deductions (up to 25%) when the property is sold. This reduces the cost basis, leading to higher capital gains, and forces a tax payment even if the property is sold at a loss or for a low price.

Is it better to depreciate a rental property or not?

There is no law that states that you have to depreciate your rental property. This is a tax advantage to lower the income tax you pay on the rental income. If you do not take the standard depreciation, then you just pay more income tax each year.

Does taking a depreciation of rental property hurt me when I sell?

Yes, you take the depreciation tax deduction. And if you don't, later on when you get around to selling the property, you will still have depreciation recapture impacting the income taxes owed - so just take the depreciation deduction each and every year on your income taxes.

What are the disadvantages of depreciation?

Disadvantages: Estimates uncertainty: useful life and residual value are being subjective, causing misstatement risk. Method choice bias: straight-line vs reducing balance vs units-of-production is affecting profit timing. Non-cash confusion: users may misinterpret depreciation as cash outflow.

Do you have to pay back depreciation on rental property?

Though depreciation itself doesn't require former property owners to pay back their deductions, the IRS does have plans in place that are designed to recapture a portion of the property's previously claimed depreciation upon its sale.

Depreciation of Rental Property

36 related questions found

Does depreciation reduce your taxes?

Tax Deductions and Depreciation

For businesses, depreciation is considered an expense. Even though it's a non-cash expense, it helps reduce taxable income.

Why is depreciation negative?

The Depreciation Expense may also become negative due to an adjustment like impairment loss or changes to the expected useful life or salvage value of your fixed assets.

What is 20% depreciation?

A 20% depreciation rate means an asset loses 20% of its value (or cost basis) each year, commonly seen in the straight-line method for a 5-year asset, but 20% also reflects a recent phase-down of bonus depreciation under the TCJA before 100% was restored for 2025+; it can also refer to specific tax credits for historic rehabilitation or the permanent 20% QBI deduction for pass-through businesses.

What are common depreciation mistakes?

Misclassification, incorrect recovery periods, and improper use of Section 179/bonus depreciation are common errors. Proper documentation and adherence to IRS guidance and industry-specific matrices are essential to avoid audit issues.

Can I claim 100% depreciation on my rental property?

Yes. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), signed into law in May 2025, has restored 100% bonus depreciation retroactively for property placed in service after December 31, 2024, and extends this full deduction through December 31, 2029.

What is the 80/20 rule for depreciation?

The "80/20 rule" in depreciation refers to two main concepts: a common real estate guideline allocating 80% of a property's cost to the depreciable building and 20% to non-depreciable land, and the IRS's 80/20 Test for determining if repowered energy property qualifies for investment tax credits by ensuring used components make up less than 20% of the value, alongside a phasing down of bonus depreciation rates, with 80% being the rate in 2023. It's not a strict IRS rule for allocation but a helpful benchmark, and the 80% bonus depreciation for other assets phased down from 100% (post-TCJA) but was restored to 100% for new acquisitions in 2025.
 

What is a 33.33 depreciation rate?

According to law, computers and other IT equipment are typically depreciable over 3 years, i.e. a 33.33% depreciation rate per year. After three years, the equipment is considered obsolete. Most companies renew their computer fleet every three years, which corresponds to an average computer's useful life.

What are the 4 types of depreciation?

The four common types of depreciation methods used in accounting are Straight-Line, Double Declining Balance, Units of Production, and Sum-of-the-Years'-Digits, each spreading an asset's cost differently over its useful life to reflect usage or decline in value, with Straight-Line being the simplest and most common.
 

Is depreciation a bad thing?

Depreciation expenses can be a benefit to a company's tax bill because they are allowed as an expense deduction and they lower the company's taxable income. This is an advantage because, while companies seek to maximize profits, they also want to seek ways to minimize taxes.

How to pay no taxes on rental income?

How do I pay no taxes on rental income in the US? Minimizing or eradicating taxes on rental income involves employing strategies such as 1031 exchanges, utilizing self-directed IRAs, claiming depreciation and deductions, leveraging equity through borrowing, deferring sales, and potentially becoming a real estate agent.

Do you get tax relief on depreciation?

Instead of claiming depreciation on your tax return, you claim capital allowances to receive tax relief on your business's capital expenditure. In short, the value of depreciation on an asset is effectively replaced by capital allowances in your tax calculation.

Is there a way around paying capital gains tax on second property?

Capital Gains Tax (CGT) is paid to HMRC on the sale of an asset that has made a profit. So, if you have a second home that you are looking to sell, how can you avoid CGT? Well, in truth you can't avoid paying CGT if the property has increased in value. But with expert help, you may be able to lower your final CGT bill.