An FHA appraisal will not pass if the home has significant health, safety, or structural issues, failing to meet Minimum Property Requirements (MPR). Common deal-breakers include peeling paint (pre-1978 homes), roof leaks or less than 2 years of life remaining, exposed wiring, major foundation issues, lack of heat/water, and broken windows.
A red flag is going to be any major defect or safety concern, such as a leaky roof, mold, or structural damage. Remember, FHA appraisers are looking for obvious hazards and structural issues that could impact the home's habitability or long-term value.
As long as the home you want to buy doesn't have major safety, security or soundness issues, it will likely pass the FHA appraisal.
FHA loan disqualifications often stem from poor credit (below 500), high debt-to-income (DTI) ratios (often above 43%), unstable employment, insufficient funds for down payment/closing costs, or issues with the property itself, like hazards or severe disrepair, plus owing back federal debts or having delinquent student loans. Clearing federal debt, establishing stable income, and ensuring the home meets safety standards are key to overcoming these hurdles, notes FHA.com and The Home Loan Expert.
Health and safety issues that can halt FHA approval
They look for hazardous building materials and finishes that are known to cause health problems in humans. This can include lead paint and asbestos in older homes. Appraisers also look for signs of mold.
The FHA 85% rule refers to a past guideline for cash-out refinances limiting the loan to 85% Loan-to-Value (LTV) and a specific rule for identity-of-interest transactions (like buying from family) where borrowers couldn't finance more than 85% of the home's value unless exceptions applied, such as renting from the family member for at least six months prior. While the general cash-out LTV is now 80%, the 85% rule still applies to certain related-party sales, requiring a 15% down payment unless an exception is met, notes FHA.com.
An FHA appraisal can require repairs before the loan is approved. That's more strict than a conventional loan.
The "3-day appraisal rule" refers to requirements under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) for mortgage lenders to provide borrowers with a free copy of the appraisal (and other valuations) at least three business days before loan closing, and to notify them of this right within three business days of application; borrowers can waive the pre-closing timing, but the lender must still provide it promptly. This ensures borrowers see the property's value before committing to the loan, though the lender must also provide it promptly upon completion, even if the loan doesn't close.
FHA appraisal and inspection checklist
Denial rates vary by loan type, though. FHA loans had a higher denial rate at 13.6%, while conventional conforming loans had the lowest at 7.9%, showing some variation depending on the program you choose. Refinance applications tend to have higher denials, with an overall rate of 32.7% in 2023.
Homes that may not pass an FHA inspection
Health and safety concerns: Properties with potential health and safety hazards, such as lead-based paint, asbestos, or mold, may not qualify for an FHA loan.
Uninsurable property is a home that is not eligible for insurance through the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) because it needs extensive repairs. An uninsurable property is typically ineligible for a mortgage through the FHA.
FHA Appraisal Checklist
Closed-end debts do not have to be included if they will be paid off within 10 months from the date of closing and the cumulative payments of all such debts are less than or equal to 5 percent of the Borrower's gross monthly income. The Borrower may not pay down the balance in order to meet the 10-month requirement.
An FHA appraisal won't pass if a property has significant health, safety, or structural hazards, like a leaky roof, exposed wiring, missing handrails, mold, or a crumbling foundation, because the FHA ensures the home is safe and habitable; issues like peeling paint (especially lead-based), broken windows/doors, inadequate heating, or pest infestations also cause failures, requiring repairs before loan approval.
FHA loan disqualifications often stem from poor credit (below 500), high debt-to-income (DTI) ratios (often above 43%), unstable employment, insufficient funds for down payment/closing costs, or issues with the property itself, like hazards or severe disrepair, plus owing back federal debts or having delinquent student loans. Clearing federal debt, establishing stable income, and ensuring the home meets safety standards are key to overcoming these hurdles, notes FHA.com and The Home Loan Expert.
Mortgage Approvals & Debts
Your total debt load plays a crucial role in determining whether you qualify for a mortgage and how much you can borrow. A high level of debt can either reduce the amount a lender is willing to offer or lead to outright rejection.
For a $400,000 house, your down payment can range from $0 to $80,000, depending on the loan type and your financial situation, with 3.5% ($14,000) for FHA loans, 3% ($12,000) for conventional loans for some first-timers, or 20% ($80,000) to avoid Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) on conventional loans, while VA and USDA loans can offer 0% down for eligible buyers.