Cashing out a whole life insurance policy is generally recommended only as a last resort, typically after holding it for 10 to 15 years to allow cash value growth, or when it is no longer needed for beneficiaries, premiums are unaffordable, or urgent funds are required. It should be done when you have sufficient assets, children are financially independent, or you face high medical costs, notes Fidelity Life.
There isn't any age cut-off that makes life insurance no longer worth it; it's all about your personal situation. That being said, it is often worth having life insurance after 65 if you have dependents who rely on you financially.
You may not be able to afford your premiums, or you might need a sum of money quickly. But price isn't the only reason you might surrender a life insurance policy. Maybe you don't need coverage anymore, you've outlived your beneficiaries or you need your money more than your beneficiaries.
A full surrender means cancelling the policy and receiving the cash value less any surrender fees. Beneficiaries won't receive any death benefit upon full surrender. There may be tax on the amount received that is above the adjusted cost basis.
Cashing out your policy
You're able to withdraw up to the amount of the total premiums you've paid into the policy without paying taxes. But if you withdraw on any gains, such as dividends, you can expect them to be taxed as ordinary income.
Fortunately, there are some strategies beneficiaries can use to avoid paying taxes on a life insurance payout, such as:
Even if you've waited for several years, cashing out the policy may not always be a good idea. Consider whether you still need the same amount of life insurance coverage and the potential tax consequences before making your decision.
The "life insurance 7 year rule," or 7-Pay Test, is an IRS test for permanent life insurance (like Whole or Universal Life) to prevent overfunding; if you pay more than the maximum premium needed to fully fund the policy in seven years, it becomes a Modified Endowment Contract (MEC). MECs lose some tax benefits, making withdrawals and loans taxable as income (earnings first) and potentially subject to penalties, though they still provide a tax-free death benefit. The test resets if you make significant changes (like increasing the death benefit) to the policy, starting a new seven-year period.
Whole life insurance provides lifelong protection to your family. Whole life insurance offers death benefit protection that can keep your family financially secure if you pass away. And because you are fully protected with your first payment, it can also be a good way to leverage your money.
Unless you're canceling a policy during a free-look period, your premium won't be refunded if you cancel your life insurance policy. There are a few instances where you may see some money returned. For example, you may receive your accumulated cash value if you cancel a permanent policy, minus any taxes and fees.
However, it may not be worth buying life insurance if: You don't have any dependents. You don't have any debt. You don't want to leave anyone an inheritance.
Unlike term insurance, whole life policies don't expire. The policy will stay in effect until you pass or until it is cancelled. Over time, the premiums you pay into the policy start to generate cash value, which can be used under certain conditions.
Whole life insurance disadvantages include high premiums compared to term life, slow cash value growth in early years (due to fees and commissions), and limited flexibility, making it hard to change coverage or stop payments without penalties, plus a long-term commitment that might not suit changing financial needs. Its complexity and the opportunity cost (money could grow faster elsewhere) are also significant drawbacks for many people, notes Thrivent and Millennium Brokers.
When a wealthy individual passes away, estate taxes, debts, and other obligations can force heirs to sell off valuable assets just to cover costs. A whole life policy provides an instant, tax-free payout to cover these expenses, allowing heirs to keep businesses, real estate, and investments intact.
Dave Ramsey advises getting term life insurance only, covering 10–12 times your annual income for a 15–20 year term, to replace lost income if you die, while investing the savings in mutual funds instead of expensive whole life policies that mix insurance with investing. He recommends policies for income-earners and stay-at-home parents, avoiding riders and focusing on simplicity to become self-insured over time.
Cancel / surrender the policy
In this situation, you'll request to surrender your policy, and you'll receive the cash value minus any fees and surrender penalties. You may have tax implications, such as if the cash value exceeds the premiums paid. On the bright side, you won't have to pay the premiums anymore.
Key Takeaways
Withdrawals, including policy loans, are tax-free up to total premiums paid unless it's a modified endowment contract. Interest earned on beneficiary life insurance proceeds or periodic (annuity) payments is generally taxable.