Why do employers ask if you're over 40?

Asked by: Sibyl Jones  |  Last update: December 25, 2025
Score: 4.3/5 (39 votes)

“Are you over the age of 40?” While it may seem like they are asking you this question to discriminate older workers, rest assured that is not the case. You will sometimes see this question when you reach an optional part of the application that inquires about your tax eligibility.

Are companies that refuse to hire workers over 40 years old guilty of age?

Age Discrimination & Employment Policies/Practices

An employment policy or practice that applies to everyone, regardless of age, can be illegal if it has a negative impact on applicants or employees age 40 or older and is not based on a reasonable factor other than age (RFOA).

Is it legal for an employer to ask your age?

At least three other states — California, Minnesota, and Pennsylvania — have enacted discrimination laws that specifically ban age questions during the hiring process.

How do employers benefit from hiring people over 40?

We heard universally that older workers bring a level of experience, critical thinking and sheer knowledge that cannot be taught. In some industries – like the jewelers, embroiderers, cabinet and cheese makers interviewed – it takes a decade or longer for workers to gain the technical skills necessary to do their job.

Is it hard to get hired at 40 years old?

All else being equal, yes, it's harder to find a job after 40. Fortunately by that age you'd likely have an extensive experience in your field, and have a managerial position. The experience and position makes it easier to find a job, so it's often a wash.

Can a salaried employee refuse to work over 40 hours per week? Can they refuse overtime?

16 related questions found

What age do employers not want to hire?

When is someone too old to work or too old to get hired? According to many employers, 62 is the cutoff for working, and 58 for hiring.

Why do job applications ask if you're over 40?

“Are you over the age of 40?” While it may seem like they are asking you this question to discriminate older workers, rest assured that is not the case. You will sometimes see this question when you reach an optional part of the application that inquires about your tax eligibility.

Why are companies reluctant to hire older workers?

The 'older' are seen as less able to adapt to tech, less ready to learn new skills, less open to innovation. While they perceive the younger as more “impressive in interviews,” and a better fit for the industry, the culture – even the team. Sadly, it's not just employers who are biased against older workers.

Why do new hires get paid more than older employees?

Employers may pay new hires more than current employees because they want to attract top talent, have access to a smaller pool of candidates, or want to reduce turnover in the absence of effective onboarding.

Do employers prefer younger or older employees?

Employers prefer to hire older workers instead of Gen Z, new study says. RALEIGH, N.C. (WNCN) — A new study by ResumeBuilder.com found 31% of all hiring managers would prefer to hire an older worker as opposed to hiring a member of Gen Z, defined as being younger than 26.

What are the 5 illegal questions to ask in an interview?

We recommend that you avoid asking applicants about personal characteristics that are protected by law, such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin or age.

What is age shaming in the workplace?

What is ageism in the workplace? Ageism in the workplace is when a candidate or employee is discriminated against because of their age. Although ageism can be experienced by both younger and older workers, it most commonly impacts those who are over 45 years of age.

Why would my boss ask my age?

There are a number of reasons why an employer may ask about an applicant's age or birthdate, primarily to verify their identity when it comes to conducting a background check. However, if the questions extend beyond a purely factual inquiry into your age or date of birth, then it can become legally problematic.

How do you prove age discrimination in hiring?

Proving age discrimination can also be found in patterns. If an employer has a pattern of hiring only younger people, promoting only younger people, and making jokes about older people, then this can be used to help prove your case. Often, these types of cases can require considerable discovery and witness testimony.

What is age discrimination by employers?

Under the ADEA it is unlawful to discriminate against any individual age 40 or older because of their age with respect to any term, condition, or privilege of employment, including but not limited to, recruitment, hiring, firing, promotion, layoff, compensation, benefits, job assignments, and training.

Can you be fired because of your age?

California law mandates that workers in California cannot be fired solely because of their age. Anyone working in California who is 40 or older is protected by these laws.

Why do companies get rid of older employees?

Many employers favor younger workers due to misconceptions and biases against older individuals, alongside concerns over costs. Some believe older employees struggle with new technology, demand higher wages and suffer from poorer health.

Why do I get paid less than my coworkers?

Pay differences may also be permitted for other reasons, including seniority (the fact that a person has a higher position within the organization or has been with the organization longer), merit (employee performance), or revenue (the amount of money the employee earns for the company).

Can two employees doing the same job be paid differently?

Under the current law, an employer can defeat an Equal Pay Act claim by proving that the difference in pay for substantially similar work is due to: seniority; merit; a system that measures production; and/or.

At what age do employers stop hiring?

The median age employers offered as “too old” was 58. Additionally, when asked at what age someone would be considered “too old” to work, 35 percent of employers picked 62 years old as the median age.

What companies like to hire older workers?

Certified Age-Friendly Employers
  • Fidelity Investments.
  • Fresenius Medical Care North America.
  • Pitney Bowes.
  • Xerox Corporation.

Do companies hire a 40 year old?

In general, you may not consider an applicant's age when making hiring decisions. There are limited exceptions to this rule. In limited circumstances, you may consider an applicant's age when making hiring decisions. You may give special hiring preference to applicants because of their older age.

Why is it hard to find a job after 40?

One common concern for older job seekers is appearing overqualified and missing out on job opportunities for this reason. At 40+ years old, it is normal to slow down to some degree, but it can be difficult for others to understand this and they may assume the job will bore you.

What are examples of age harassment?

Age harassment can include age-based jokes or comments, offensive cartoons, drawing, symbols, or gestures, and other verbal and physical conduct based on an individual's age.

What happens if an interviewer asks about your age?

Any interview question that asks about your age or infers how old you are is employment discrimination and illegal for interviewers to ask — period. Many interviewers know to avoid those questions, yet some will still ask job seekers some variation of the question, "How old are you?"