Why is DCF better than comparables?

Asked by: Phyllis Hyatt  |  Last update: April 1, 2025
Score: 4.9/5 (22 votes)

Generally, DCF is more suitable for valuing businesses that have stable and predictable cash flows, high growth potential, or significant competitive advantages; for businesses that are not comparable to other businesses in the same industry or sector; or for businesses that are undergoing significant changes or ...

When to use DCF vs Comparables?

Company Stage and Industry: DCF may be suitable for stable, mature companies with predictable cash flows, while Comparable Companies Analysis may be apt for industries with multiple comparable companies.

Why is DCF the best valuation method?

DCF Valuation truly captures the underlying fundamental drivers of a business (cost of equity, weighted average cost of capital, growth rate, re-investment rate, etc.). Consequently, this comes closest to estimating intrinsic value of the asset/business. Unlike other valuations, DCF relies on Free Cash Flows.

What are the advantages of the DCF model?

The main Pros of a DCF model are:

Extremely detailed. Includes all major assumptions about the business. Determines the “intrinsic” value of a business. Does not require any comparable companies.

What is a disadvantage of using the comparables method for equity valuation?

Disadvantages. It is difficult to identify transactions or companies that are comparable. There is usually a lack of a sufficient number of comparable companies or transactions. It is less flexible compared to other methods.

Warren Buffett Brilliantly Explains Discounted Cash Flow Analysis + Example! (How to Value a Stock!)

18 related questions found

Which valuation method is most accurate?

Discounted Cash Flow Analysis (DCF)

In this respect, DCF is the most theoretically correct of all of the valuation methods because it is the most precise.

What is the difference between DCF and CCF?

As a result, the DCF is often referred to a two-stage valuation model, as opposed to the CCF which is a single-stage model. The DCF method can be utilized when a company's future growth trend is projected to be non-linear, such as growth at 20% in year 1, 15% in year 2 and 5% in year 3.

What is the biggest drawback of the DCF?

Sensitivity to Assumptions

The reliance on assumptions is the main drawback of the DCF approach, in which minor adjustments to key assumptions could have material impacts on the DCF valuation.

When should you not use DCF?

We do not use a DCF if the company has unstable or unpredictable cash flows (tech or bio-tech start-up) or when debt and working capital serve a fundamentally different role.

What are the advantages of the elaboration likelihood model?

One of the strengths of the ELM is its ability to explain the complex cognitive processes that underlie persuasion. By distinguishing between the central and peripheral routes, the ELM provides a framework for understanding how people make decisions based on different types of information.

What are the top 3 major problems with DCF valuation?

Problems With DCF
  • Operating Cash Flow Projections.
  • Capital Expenditure Projections.
  • Discount Rate and Growth Rate.

What is the best valuation method?

Discounted Cash Flow Valuation

DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) can provide an accurate assessment of probable future business earnings. DCF estimates the company's value based on the future or projected cash flow. This is a good method to use because sometimes the business will be worth more than you think.

What are the criticisms of DCF?

One primary challenge with DCF analysis lies in its dependence on assumptions. Projections of future cash flows, growth rates, discount rates, and terminal values heavily influence the valuation.

Why is equity valuation important?

Importance of Equity Valuation: Systemic

The art and science of equity valuation therefore enables the modern economic system to efficiently allocate scare capital resources amongst various market participants.

Is it better to use levered or unlevered DCF?

A levered DCF therefore attempts to value the Equity portion of a company's capital structure directly, while an unlevered DCF analysis attempts to value the company as a whole; at the end of the unlevered DCF analysis, Net Debt and other claims can be subtracted out to arrive at the residual (Equity) value of the ...

What is the comparable valuation method?

Comparable Company Analysis is a relative valuation method in which a company's value is derived from comparisons to the current stock prices of similar companies in the market.

What is the difference between DCF and comparable analysis?

Comparable company analysis (or “comps” for short) is a valuation methodology that looks at ratios of similar public companies and uses them to derive the value of another business. Comps is a relative form of valuation, unlike a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis, which is an intrinsic form of valuation.

What are the strengths of DCF?

DCF analysis has both strengths and weaknesses. Its strengths include: The requirement to think about and forecast key business drivers leads to a fuller understanding of the fundamentals. It is an important counterpoint to market-based valuation techniques (avoiding some of the possible market distortions)

When to use DCF and when to use relative valuation?

However, some general guidelines to consider are using DCF to estimate intrinsic value based on cash flows and risk if reliable data is available; relative valuation to estimate market value based on performance and quality if a sufficient set of comparable assets is available; and using both methods to cross-check ...

What is a disadvantage of the free cash flow valuation method?

A disadvantage of the free cash flow valuation method is: The terminal value tends to dominate the total value in many cases. The projection of free cash flows depends on earnings estimates. The free cash flow method is not rigorous.

Is DCF analysis accurate?

While the discounted cash flow (DCF) methodology is the most rigorous and financially sound for business valuation, it does have several significant limitations, namely: Extreme sensitivity to certain input assumptions. Uncertainty in calculating the terminal value of the company.

What variables are sensitive to DCF analysis?

A discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis is highly sensitive to key variables such as the long-term growth rate (in the growth perpetuity version of the terminal value) and the weighted average cost of capital (WACC).

When to use a DCF?

As such, a DCF analysis can be useful in any situation where a person is paying money in the present with expectations of receiving more money in the future. For example, assuming a 5% annual interest rate, $1 in a savings account will be worth $1.05 in a year.

Why do traditional valuation models like discounted cash flow?

Question: Why do traditional valuation models, like discounted cash flow, fail at capturing the full range of risks companies face today? They offer limited, deterministic and potentially misleading insights. They do not consider compliance risk.

What are the alternatives to the DCF model?

The most common variations of the DCF model are the dividend discount model (DDM) and the free cash flow (FCF) model, which, in turn, has two forms: free cash flow to equity (FCFE) and free cash flow to firm (FCFF) models.