Your W-2 Box 1 (Taxable Wages) is lower than your annual salary because it reflects your gross pay minus pre-tax deductions, not your total salary. Common pre-tax items lowering your W-2 amount include retirement contributions (401(k)), health/dental/vision insurance premiums, and Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs/HSAs).
On your W-2, that number is taxable income, so money put into your 401k and health insurance premiums are subtracted generally so you don't pay tax on that stuff. Most likely the $5k discrepancy is your 401k or health insurance deductions.
Once you add in your second W2, you are showing income for the last 2 months. Now that over estimation from the first W2 calculation is corrected, hence the drop in refund amount.
Why is the gross amount on my final pay of the year different from the amount on my W-2? Final pay stub shows the total or gross dollar amount earned before taxes and deductions and the amount the employee actually receives (net pay). Form W-2 shows taxable wages reported after pre-tax deductions.
Yes, it's possible for your employer to mess up your W-2 or neglect to send it. Some employers are bad at bookkeeping, or your employer might have gone out of business or been acquired by another firm. If you moved, your employer might not have your new address.
If by the end of February, your Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement has not been corrected by your employer after you attempted to have your employer or payer issue a corrected form, you can request that an IRS representative initiate a Form W-2 complaint.
There are three easy steps to make sure your W-2 is correct:
If you have any pretax deductions like insurance or retirement plans your W2 will be different from your total gross wages.
The answer is yes, you must file every W-2 you received during the tax year when filing your tax return. Each company you worked for during the year is required to send you a Form W-2 and send the form to the SSA as well.
The biggest tax mistakes people make include filing late, math errors, incorrect personal info (like Social Security numbers), forgetting deductions/credits (like EITC), misreporting income, not signing forms, and making errors with bank details for direct deposit, all leading to delays, penalties, or missed savings, with using tax software or professionals helping avoid these common pitfalls.
Your employer might have just made a mistake. If your employer didn't have federal tax withheld from your paychecks, contact them to have the correct amount withheld for the future. When you file your tax return, you'll owe the amounts your employer should have withheld during the year as unpaid taxes.
Call the IRS toll free at 800-829-1040 or make an appointment to visit an IRS taxpayer assistance center (TAC). The IRS will send your employer a letter requesting that they furnish you a corrected Form W-2 within ten days.
Another common question is, “Why does my W-2 not match my salary?” Your salary is the total amount earned before any deductions. However, your W-2 reflects taxable wages, which are reduced by pre-tax deductions such as 401(k) or health insurance. Therefore, the W-2 amount is usually lower.
Common Errors on Your W-2
Box 2 on our W2 is the amount of tax withheld from your wages. However, this does not tell you how much you will get back. On your form 1040, you will see your refund on line 34. If you owe, the amount will be on line 37.
Not reporting all of your income is an easy-to-avoid red flag that can lead to an audit. Taking excessive business tax deductions and mixing business and personal expenses can lead to an audit. The IRS mostly audits tax returns of those earning more than $200,000 and corporations with more than $10 million in assets.