Is it better to pay a collection agency or the original creditor?

Asked by: Mrs. Gudrun Kuhlman  |  Last update: October 25, 2022
Score: 5/5 (14 votes)

Working with the original creditor, rather than dealing with debt collectors, can be beneficial. Often, the original creditor will offer a more reasonable payment option, reduce the balance on your original loan or even stop interest from accruing on the loan balance altogether.

What happens if I pay original creditor instead of collection agency?

If your debt has passed into collections, it'll put a hefty ding in your credit score. But paying it off may not fix that. Paying a debt collection agency may do more harm than good to your credit score. That's because actually paying your debt will lower your credit score.

Is it better to make payments or pay in full collections?

It is always better to pay off your debt in full if possible. While settling an account won't damage your credit as much as not paying at all, a status of "settled" on your credit report is still considered negative.

Why should I not pay a collection agency?

Making a payment on the debt will likely reset the statute of limitations — which is disastrous. If the collection agency can't show ownership of the debt. Frequently, the sale of a debt from a creditor to a collector is sloppy. A collection agency hounding you may not be able to show they actually own your debt.

Can original creditor remove collection?

Getting Collectors to Remove Negative Information

The collection agency might tell you that they can't make that decision—only the original creditor can remove the information. Ask for the name and phone number of the person with the original creditor who has the authority to make this decision.

Pay original creditor but collector still shows a balance on credit report?

42 related questions found

How many points will my credit score increase when I pay off collections?

Contrary to what many consumers think, paying off an account that's gone to collections will not improve your credit score.

Is it worth it to pay off collections?

It's always a good idea to pay collection debts you legitimately owe. Paying or settling collections will end the harassing phone calls and collection letters, and it will prevent the debt collector from suing you.

Can you have a 700 credit score with collections?

Yes, it is possible to have a credit score of at least 700 with a collections remark on your credit report, however it is not a common situation. It depends on several contributing factors such as: differences in the scoring models being used.

Will paying a debt collector hurt my credit?

Collections remain on your credit report for seven years past the date of delinquency. In the newest versions of FICO® and VantageScore®, paid collections don't hurt your score but unpaid collections do.

How long after paying a collection will it be removed?

However, on a credit report, a paid collection can still stay on your credit report for up to seven years, regardless of whether the account has a $0 balance. After seven years, the paid collection will automatically drop off your credit report.

Should I take a settlement from a collection agency?

Offer a Lump-Sum Settlement

If you decide to offer a lump sum to pay off the debt for less than you owe, understand that no general rule applies to all collection agencies. Some want 75%–80% of what you owe. Others will take 50%, while others might settle for one-third or less.

Does paid in full increase credit score?

Some credit scoring models exclude collection accounts once they are paid in full, so you could experience a credit score increase as soon as the collection is reported as paid. Most lenders view a collection account that has been paid in full as more favorable than an unpaid collection account.

What percentage should I offer to settle debt?

When you're negotiating with a creditor, try to settle your debt for 50% or less, which is a realistic goal based on creditors' history with debt settlement. If you owe $3,000, shoot for a settlement of up to $1,500.

How do I remove a collection from my credit report?

You can ask the current creditor — either the original creditor or a debt collector — for what's called a “goodwill deletion.” Write the collector a letter explaining your circumstances and why you would like the debt removed, such as if you're about to apply for a mortgage.

Should I pay a 5 year old collection?

If you have a collection account that's less than seven years old, you should still pay it off if it's within the statute of limitations. First, a creditor can bring legal action against you, including garnishing your salary or your bank account, at least until the statute of limitations expires.

How do you ask for goodwill deletion?

If your misstep happened because of unfortunate circumstances like a personal emergency or a technical error, try writing a goodwill letter to ask the creditor to consider removing it. The creditor or collection agency may ask the credit bureaus to remove the negative mark.

Is Creditkarma accurate?

The credit scores and reports you see on Credit Karma should accurately reflect your credit information as reported by those bureaus. This means a couple of things: The scores we provide are actual credit scores pulled from two of the major consumer credit bureaus, not just estimates of your credit rating.

What happens when you pay off a collection?

Paying won't take a collections account off your credit reports. Many people believe paying off an account in collections will remove the negative mark from their credit reports. This isn't true; if you pay an account in collections in full, it will show up on your credit report as “paid,” but it won't disappear.

What is the 11 word phrase to stop debt collectors?

The first step to stopping debt collectors from calling you is telling them the 11-word phrase - “Please cease and desist all calls and contact with me, immediately.”

What are the cons of debt settlement?

Disadvantages of Debt Settlement
  • Debt Settlement Fees. Many debt settlement providers charge high fees, sometimes $500-$3,000, or more. ...
  • Debt Settlement Impact on Credit Score. ...
  • Holding Funds. ...
  • Debt Settlement Tax Implications. ...
  • Creditors Could Refuse to Negotiate Your Debt. ...
  • You May End Up with More Debt Than You Started.

How do you get an 800 credit score?

How to Get an 800 Credit Score
  1. Pay Your Bills on Time, Every Time. Perhaps the best way to show lenders you're a responsible borrower is to pay your bills on time. ...
  2. Keep Your Credit Card Balances Low. ...
  3. Be Mindful of Your Credit History. ...
  4. Improve Your Credit Mix. ...
  5. Review Your Credit Reports.

How can I raise my credit score by 100 points in 30 days?

  1. Lower your credit utilization rate. The fastest way to get a credit score boost is to lower the amount of revolving debt (which is generally credit cards) you're carrying. ...
  2. Ask for late payment forgiveness. ...
  3. Dispute inaccurate information on your credit reports. ...
  4. Add utility and phone payments to your credit report.

How fast does your credit score go up after paying debt?

How long does it take for my credit score to update after paying off debt? It can often take as long as one to two months for debt payment information to be reflected on your credit score. This has to do with both the timing of credit card and loan billing cycles and the monthly reporting process followed by lenders.

How many points does a settlement affect credit score?

Does Debt Settlement Hurt Your Credit? Debt settlement affects your credit for up to 7 years, lowering your credit score by as much as 100 points initially and then having less of an effect as time goes on. The events that typically lead up to debt settlement will affect your credit score, too.

What happens if I settle debt with collection agency?

Once you settle the account, the collection agency will contact the credit reporting companies and update the account to reflect that it has been settled, but for less than originally agreed. In most cases, your account will reflect the change within a month or two of the collection company receiving your payment.