What are the downsides of a discretionary trust?

Asked by: Prof. Reuben Koch DDS  |  Last update: January 10, 2026
Score: 4.8/5 (50 votes)

Disadvantages:
  • Complexity: Trusts can be complex and difficult to set up and manage. ...
  • Cost: Setting up and maintaining a trust can be expensive due to legal and yearly accounting fees. ...
  • Loss of control: Once assets are transferred to a trust, the grantor loses direct control over them.

Is it worth setting up a discretionary trust?

There are a huge number of advantages to utilising a discretionary trust including: ease of distribution of income and capital. flexibility over the appointment of trustees and nomination of beneficiaries (see below)

Who owns the assets in a discretionary trust?

Trustees. The trustees are the legal owners of the assets held in a trust. Their role is to: deal with the assets according to the settlor's wishes, as set out in the trust deed or their will.

What happens to a discretionary trust when the trustee dies?

Discretionary Trust assets do not form part of your Estate

Even if you are the personal trustee of your family trust, the trust will usually continue to have life after your death. The assets are not “your” personally owned assets that are part of your estate to be gifted via your Will.

Why do people use discretionary trusts?

If flexibility is important to you, a discretionary trust may be the best option. It provides asset protection in that it can prevent a beneficiary's creditors from accessing key assets. Therefore, if a business goes bankrupt, creditors won't be able to touch any property held in the discretionary trust.

What are the benefits of discretionary trusts and should I use one?

39 related questions found

What happens to money in a discretionary trust?

Discretionary trusts are sometimes set up to put assets aside for: a future need, like a grandchild who may need more financial help than other beneficiaries at some point in their life. beneficiaries who are not capable or responsible enough to deal with money themselves.

Who controls a discretionary trust?

An entity controls the discretionary trust if the trustee either acts, or might reasonably be expected to act, in accordance with the directions or wishes of the entity/or the entity's affiliates, or both the entity and its affiliates.

Can creditors go after a discretionary trust?

Since the purpose of the trust is to provide support for the beneficiary, he cannot alienate his interest in the trust. Thus, the beneficiary's creditors cannot attach the funds in the trust.

How does a discretionary trust fail?

If a discretionary trust is set up during the settlor's lifetime, the assets within that trust may fall outside their own estate if they die at least seven years after putting the assets into the trust.

What is the difference between a family trust and a discretionary trust?

The difference between a discretionary trust and other types of trust structures is that the trustee exercises complete discretion regarding distributing the relevant income and/or capital amongst the beneficiaries as per the trust deed. The most common example of this type of structure is a family trust.

What is the 10 year charge on a discretionary trust?

How is the 10-Year Charge calculated? The calculation of the 10-Year Charge for discretionary trusts, classified as 'relevant property' trusts, requires evaluating the total trust assets against the nil-rate band and applying a 6% tax rate on any excess value.

How to avoid inheritance tax with a trust?

An irrevocable trust transfers asset ownership from the original owner to the trust, with assets eventually distributed to the beneficiaries. Because those assets don't legally belong to the person who set up the trust, they aren't subject to estate or inheritance taxes when that person passes away.

At what net worth do I need a trust?

Many advisors and attorneys recommend a $100K minimum net worth for a living trust. However, there are other factors to consider depending on your personal situation. What is your age, marital status, and earning potential?

How much is a discretionary trust fee?

A chargeable lifetime transfer (CLT) is a transfer of value made by an individual during their lifetime which is subject to Inheritance Tax (IHT). The transfer of value is usually made to another person or trust, including a discretionary trust. It is levied at the rate of 20% of the chargeable transfer of value.

How much income is taxed in a trust?

Federal trust income tax rates for 2023 were: For trust income between $0 to $2,900: 10% of income over $0. For trust income between $2,901 to $10,550: $290 + 24% of the amount over $2,901. For trust income between $10,551 to $14,450: $2,126 + 35% of the amount over $10,551.

How do you get money out of a discretionary trust?

Beneficiaries of a discretionary trust are not entitled to receive anything as of right. Instead the beneficiaries have the potential to receive money and the right to ask the trustees to exercise their discretion in their favour.

What are the disadvantages of a discretionary trust?

Disadvantages of discretionary trusts

Not all potential beneficiaries are guaranteed to benefit. As who benefits and by how much is left up to the discretion of the trustees, some potential beneficiaries who the settlor had intended to benefit may not.

What happens at the end of a discretionary trust?

Other trusts, such as Discretionary Trusts, usually end when the trustees exercise their powers to bring the trust to an end and distribute all of the assets. When taking steps to end a trust, trustees should consider: Recording their final actions in trustee minutes.

Can you remove a beneficiary from a discretionary trust?

If it is a discretionary trust, you may not have to do much to exclude a beneficiary. The trustee has the discretionary power to exclude beneficiaries from the trust. However, the trustee must act in good faith and for the benefit of the beneficiaries.

Who benefits from a discretionary trust?

Unlike many other trusts, a discretionary trust fund allows you to make financial provision in a way that does not affect means-tested benefits or entitlements. The future is a worry for many people who have a relative or friend with a learning disability or autism. We can help reduce that worry.

What is the best trust to avoid creditors?

An irrevocable trust offers your assets the most protection from creditors and lawsuits. Assets in an irrevocable trust aren't considered personal property. This means they're not included when the IRS values your estate to determine if taxes are owed.

Can a discretionary trust distribute to a deceased person?

Yes, if a beneficiary dies then the trustee may make a distribution to the beneficiary's estate - the Cleardocs discretionary trust deed has 2 requirements to allow for this: There must be a testamentary trust in the deceased beneficiary's will; and.

What is the biggest mistake parents make when setting up a trust fund?

Selecting the wrong trustee is easily the biggest blunder parents can make when setting up a trust fund. As estate planning attorneys, we've seen first-hand how this critical error undermines so many parents' good intentions.

Who is the ultimate beneficial owner of a discretionary trust?

In the case of a Discretionary Trust, the Trustee has legal control of the funds. Therefore, they are the legal owner. However, the funds are held and distributed to benefit the beneficiaries. The beneficiaries are the beneficial owners.

Who has more right, a trustee or the beneficiary?

A trustee typically has the most control in running their trust. They are granted authority by their grantor to oversee and distribute assets according to terms set out in their trust document, while beneficiaries merely reap its benefits without overseeing its operations themselves.